‘The Westies’ Season 1 Review: A Gangster Tale with Historical Roots and a Search for Identity
New York gangster narratives have long been a staple of prestige television, and MGM+ recognizes the demand for another addition to this genre. ‘The Westies’ is set in 1980s Hell’s Kitchen, telling the true story of the Irish American crime gang that established its territory alongside the much larger Italian mafia, with the construction of the Jacob Javits Convention Center serving as the backdrop for its central conflict.
The premise holds significant potential, and the production team has clearly invested effort into recreating the period’s atmosphere. Smoke-filled bars, classic sedans, and a gritty soundtrack effectively transport viewers to 1980s Manhattan, even though the series was filmed in Toronto. While the costuming sometimes blurs the lines between the late 70s and early 90s styles, the overall ambiance remains impactful.
The season truly shines through its cast. J.K. Simmons leads the show as Eamon Sweeney, portraying him with a working-class charm that occasionally reveals a colder, more menacing side. Tom Brittney complements him perfectly as Jimmy Roarke, Sweeney’s most trusted enforcer, and their mentor-mentee relationship provides the season with its most engaging narrative thread, even when the surrounding writing opts for a safer approach than the genre typically demands.
Titus Welliver deserves notable recognition for his role as Glenn Keenan, an informant caught between law enforcement and the criminal world he is supposed to report on. He infuses the character with a sense of weariness that suggests deeper emotional scars, elevating scenes that might otherwise rely on familiar genre tropes.
Sarah Bolger’s Bridget adds depth as an IRA operative drawn back into past entanglements, although her romance with Jimmy occasionally feels repetitive, with both characters spending an unusual amount of time cautioning each other to stay safe.
This romance highlights the season’s primary flaw: a tendency to rely on well-trodden beats rather than crafting a narrative that feels uniquely its own. The portrayal of John Gotti and the broader Italian mafia rivalry comes across as a mere amalgamation of gangster clichés audiences have encountered numerous times, and much of the emotional weight attributed to Sweeney’s internal struggles feels more dictated by the plot than genuinely developed through the writing.
Mickey Flanagan’s storyline as a Vietnam veteran grappling with PTSD hints at deeper themes, but the show seldom delves deeply enough into that trauma to resonate as powerfully as it aspires to.
Visually, the series adopts the muted, desaturated aesthetic that has become common in prestige streaming television, occasionally interrupted by genuinely dynamic and well-edited action sequences that prioritize a raw, instinctive style of street fighting over polished choreography. The direction often opts for competence rather than the bold visual ambition that has characterized the genre’s true masterpieces, although a few episodes do exhibit flashes of creativity when the show allows itself to experiment.
None of this renders ‘The Westies’ an unenjoyable experience. The eight-episode run moves swiftly, never overstaying its welcome, and the chemistry between the lead performances generates genuine momentum, even during the more formulaic segments. However, it lacks the sense of danger and moral complexity that distinguishes the genre’s finest works, leaving Sweeney feeling more like a beloved uncle than a figure capable of real menace.
As the season concludes, it wraps up its central conflicts satisfactorily while leaving enough loose ends for a potential second season, should MGM+ decide to proceed. I found myself entertained by the performances yet mildly frustrated by how seldom the writing matched their aspirations, resulting in a solid 7 out of 10 for a season that is enjoyable in the moment but unlikely to leave a lasting impression after the credits roll.
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!