Chris Carter Still Wants to Finish Mulder and Scully’s Story from The X-Files

Few sci-fi dramas have made as significant an impact on pop culture as ‘The X-Files,’ and even years after its debut, fans remain eager for clarity on Mulder and Scully’s ultimate fate. The franchise has seen numerous iterations, from its original nine-season run to two feature films and two revival seasons.

This desire for closure has intensified with discussions of a new take on the franchise, led by a completely different creative team. With so much unresolved narrative surrounding the original mythology, fans have long speculated whether creator Chris Carter has more stories to share.

In a recent interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Carter confirmed that he indeed has a “bigger plan” for Mulder and Scully that he hopes to unveil. Reflecting on the controversial ending of the show’s eleventh season, Carter noted that everything fans witnessed, including some polarizing decisions, was part of a larger narrative.

“I think I didn’t give the audience what they expected,” Carter stated in the interview with The Hollywood Reporter. “And that is left to come. There are four episodes and the last two reboots that were all part of a bigger plan that I hope to reveal to X-Files fans if and when we should do another reboot.”

Carter addressed the backlash surrounding certain story choices, particularly the season 11 finale twist revealing Scully’s pregnancy. “There was a big revelation at the end of the season finale in season 11 that Scully is pregnant. Some people were horrified, outraged. They hated me,” Carter remarked, framing the moment as part of a longer narrative he still wishes to complete.

He also defended the broader creative decisions behind those contentious choices, asserting that delivering precisely what fans anticipated was never the aim. “There’s a point at which you need to deliver on a promise. And I wanted to deliver more than the promise. I wanted to give them what they least expected,” Carter explained in the interview with The Hollywood Reporter, adding that the plan, while perplexing at the time, will eventually “make sense.”

This discussion comes as Ryan Coogler continues to develop his own reimagining of the franchise for Hulu, collaborating with showrunner Jennifer Yale on a project that reportedly features Danielle Deadwyler and Himesh Patel. Carter emphasized that he has no intention of interfering with that project, positioning his potential return as a separate endeavor rather than a competing one.

“The thing that was unexpected, but now highly anticipated, is the Ryan Coogler reboot. I don’t want to do anything to compete with that. I don’t want to do anything to get in the way of that. I don’t want to play off of that,” Carter said in the interview with The Hollywood Reporter. “I want to continue to tell and finish the story arc that I have in mind.”

This distinction is crucial for fans trying to understand what might be next. Coogler’s version is being developed as a reboot with a new, more diverse cast rather than a continuation featuring David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson, meaning Carter’s aspirations for a Mulder and Scully return would exist as a completely separate project if it ever materializes.

For now, both projects remain in various stages of uncertainty, leaving longtime fans with two distinct paths back into the world of the paranormal. Whether Carter will ever have the opportunity to conclude his original vision is still uncertain, but his comments make one thing clear: he’s not ready to let Mulder and Scully’s story end where season 11 left off.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!