Audiences Show More Love than Critics for Ridley Scott’s ‘The Dog Stars’

The gap between critical consensus and audience reaction can often be striking, and few recent films exemplify this better than Ridley Scott’s latest foray into post-apocalyptic storytelling. When a filmmaker’s confidence in their project meets a challenging critical reception, it creates a narrative all its own.

‘The Dog Stars,’ an adaptation of Peter Heller’s celebrated 2012 novel, hit theaters this week with high expectations, fueled by Scott’s own enthusiastic comments and a cast featuring Jacob Elordi and Josh Brolin. However, that confidence hasn’t translated seamlessly into critical acclaim, resulting in a noticeably divided reception.

With audience ratings now available, this divide has become even clearer. The film boasts a respectable 71 percent audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, according to ScreenRant, based on over 100 verified ratings, which sharply contrasts with its weaker critical reviews.

This audience score stands alongside a mere 40 percent Tomatometer rating from more than 150 professional reviews, highlighting a significant 31-point disparity between critics and general viewers. For context, this marks the largest critic-audience gap for any Scott film since 2006’s ‘A Good Year,’ which had a 26 percent critic score against a 66 percent audience rating.

This critical reception presents a challenging moment for the 88-year-old director, as his 40 percent Tomatometer score is now his lowest-rated film of the decade. It also reflects his weakest critical performance since 2014’s ‘Exodus: Gods and Kings,’ especially given Scott’s own remarks calling ‘The Dog Stars’ possibly his best work since ‘The Martian.’

Critics have primarily pointed out issues with the film’s pacing, awkward narrative transitions between its dual storylines, and a perceived failure to capture the emotional depth of Heller’s original material. Nevertheless, some reviewers have praised Elordi and Margaret Qualley’s performances as standout elements that enhance the film’s character-driven narrative.

This contrast between overall reception and specific commendations for the cast may explain why audiences are responding more favorably than critics. Even those outlets that delivered mixed reviews acknowledged the film’s stunning visuals and emotionally impactful performances, aspects that seem to resonate more with general viewers than with critics focusing on broader structural critiques.

The film follows Hig, a former civilian pilot portrayed by Elordi, as he navigates a post-apocalyptic landscape following a devastating flu pandemic, alongside Bangley, a tough former Marine played by Brolin. Despite facing box office challenges and mixed critical feedback, the film’s unexpectedly strong audience score offers a glimmer of hope for a release that has encountered significant obstacles since its premiere.

Whether this audience enthusiasm translates into stronger word-of-mouth in the coming weeks remains to be seen, especially considering the film’s soft opening weekend numbers. Still, a 71 percent audience score suggests that ‘The Dog Stars’ may resonate more with general viewers than its critical reception would imply.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!