A24’s ‘Tony’ Achieves Unprecedented Success for a Biopic

Biopics often struggle with critics, frequently falling into predictable patterns that transform intriguing real-life figures into formulaic award contenders. Thus, it’s particularly impressive when a film about a real person manages to completely overcome that skepticism.

‘Tony‘ comes from director Matt Johnson, known for his work on ‘BlackBerry’ and ‘Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie.’ His improvisational storytelling style keeps his films feeling vibrant and spontaneous. In this instance, he applies that same energy to a fictionalized account of a pivotal summer in the life of Anthony Bourdain, long before he became a renowned chef and author.

This unique approach has yielded remarkable results. ‘Tony’ premiered with a perfect 100 percent score on Rotten Tomatoes, a rare achievement for a biographical drama, with the film receiving widespread acclaim from major critics as the review embargo lifted.

Dominic Sessa, recognized for his role in ‘The Holdovers,’ plays a 19-year-old Bourdain, a confident aspiring writer whose ambitions are derailed after missing a fellowship at Vassar. Instead of sticking to his original plan, he follows a young woman named Nancy, portrayed by Emilia Jones, to Provincetown. There, a summer spent working in a restaurant kitchen alongside a charismatic cook named Sal, played by Leo Woodall, sets him on an unexpected journey toward the career that would ultimately define him.

Critics have consistently commended the film for avoiding the usual biopic formula. Rather than chronicling Bourdain’s ascent to fame, ‘Tony’ focuses on a single, transformative summer, presenting itself more as a coming-of-age story loosely inspired by real events.

Much of the praise has been directed at Sessa’s performance, which many reviewers highlight as a true star-making moment. Variety noted that he fully embraces leading-man territory, capturing both Bourdain’s simmering anger and emotional vulnerability, elevating the film beyond typical summer indie offerings.

Antonio Banderas has also garnered attention for his supporting role as a mentor figure known simply as “Chef.” Reviewers have pointed out a quiet yet impactful scene where the two create ketchup from scratch as one of the film’s standout moments. The supporting cast features Dagmara Domińczyk, Rich Sommer, Stavros Halkias, and Monica Raymund.

While not every critic deemed the film a complete triumph, with some suggesting it refrains from making Bourdain fully likable, the overall consensus remains overwhelmingly positive. This nuanced characterization, rather than a sanitized, hero-worship narrative, seems to resonate with critics who are weary of clichéd biographical storytelling.

Loosely based on elements from Bourdain’s memoir ‘Kitchen Confidential,’ the film takes creative liberties with the specifics of this period in his life while capturing the restless, rebellious spirit that would come to define his voice as a writer and chef. This blend of fiction and biography contributes to ‘Tony’ feeling fresh and innovative.

With A24 supporting the release and set to bring ‘Tony’ to theaters in August, the film’s flawless critical debut positions it as one of the more surprising awards-season contenders of the year. Given how infrequently biopics achieve this level of universal acclaim, Sessa’s standout performance is likely to make this one of the most discussed films of the late summer.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!