‘Average Joe’ Season 2 Episode 7 Recap and Ending Explained: Joe Confronts Teddy in the Castle

voice film logo squareArthur S. Poe
Average Joe season 2
Share:

Few dark comedies blend bloody chaos with family drama as effectively as ‘Average Joe’, and the second season on Paramount+ has been building toward a significant confrontation. The name of Teddy Washington has loomed large since the pilot episode. This recap and ending explanation details the moment Joe finally faces his father.

The story traces back to the first season, which followed Pittsburgh plumber Joe Washington as he uncovered his father’s secret life as a courier for the Russian mob after his death. Teddy had also stolen $10 million and a rare Lamborghini from the mob’s boss. This season, Joe recruits his friends Leon, Cathy, and Touch to track a threat against his family to Cape Town, South Africa, where a young woman named Imani claims to be Teddy’s daughter and insists he is still alive.

The tension culminates in Season 2 Episode 7, “Simple Pleasure,” which premiered on September 23 as the penultimate episode of the eight-part series. Joe finally meets Teddy face-to-face, and TV Fanatic’s review describes their encounter as filled with anger, resentment, and years of emotional neglect, all set in a prison located in a castle basement.

Across from his father, Joe appears to be a mere shadow of himself, showing genuine warmth only when discussing his beloved Pittsburgh Steelers. Teddy, on the other hand, quickly reveals himself to be a man who seems perpetually distracted. The two even engage in a conversation about Kenny Pickett, treating the quarterback as if he were a potential savior for the Steelers.

However, the reunion soon takes a turn for the worse. Teddy attempts to provoke Joe, suggesting that they are cut from the same cloth, which leads Joe to unleash years of pent-up frustration in a fistfight. The reviewer notes that while the scuffle felt somewhat absurd given the circumstances, it was a long-overdue release of tension.

Fans seeking answers do get some, albeit in a way that feels anticlimactic. Teddy reveals his entire plan, and the review describes his delivery as an info dump that, while unsettling, lacked the emotional weight one might expect given the destruction he has caused.

One of the most painful moments comes when Teddy discusses Imani and her mother, who was killed earlier in the season. Imani believed she had a loving relationship with her father, contrasting sharply with Joe’s cold experience. This heartbreaking juxtaposition suggests that Joe may have been the son Teddy cared for, in his own twisted manner.

Screenshot 2026 09 10 at 09 29 47 Average Joe 2023 Rotten Tomatoes

While Joe confronts his father, Touch and Leon work together to infiltrate Sipho’s heavily fortified castle without drawing attention. Their chemistry and comedic timing help lighten the mood, a hallmark of the show.

Leon eventually discovers Cathy trapped in a tower, a twist the reviewer anticipated. However, a quiet moment between Touch and Phyllis takes the audience by surprise, hinting at a budding romance that feels well-earned after a season of development.

The episode concludes with all characters—Joe, Touch, Leon, Cathy, and Phyllis—gathered under one roof in Sipho’s castle. This convergence sets the stage for the upcoming finale, which is set to air on September 30. However, the reviewer points out that the season’s biggest flaw has been attempting to cram too much plot into each hour.

Cathy’s fate remains a delicate thread. Prior to this episode, she had contacted the police and gloated that everyone, including her own husband, could face jail time. Even if she manages to save the day, Leon must grapple with whether love can endure a betrayal that he may never fully trust again.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments.

Share: