The One Hollywood Legend Clint Eastwood and Robert Redford Both Idolized

Clint Eastwood and Robert Redford stand as two of the most significant figures in cinema history, defining an entire era of filmmaking. While Eastwood cemented his legacy as the rugged, stoic anti-hero, Redford was often seen as the polished, golden boy of the screen. Despite these contrasting public images, both men successfully transitioned from acting to directing, earning Academy Awards for their work behind the camera.

Their careers took different paths, with Eastwood often staying within his established wheelhouse and Redford constantly fighting to be taken seriously beyond his looks. Yet, despite their different approaches to stardom, they shared a singular opinion regarding the craft of acting. Both legends identified the same man as the greatest performer to ever step in front of a camera.

That shared idol was James Cagney, the dynamic star known for his explosive energy and versatility. Eastwood, who was famously reserved with his praise, once admitted that he was never truly a fan of any actor except for Cagney. He described the connection between the actor and the medium by saying that movies were invented for Cagney, and Cagney was invented for movies.

Robert Redford held a similarly high regard for the screen icon. He frequently cited Cagney as a major inspiration, simply stating that he admired him and considered him an incredible talent. This mutual respect highlights how Cagney’s raw power and authenticity transcended the different styles Eastwood and Redford represented.

They were not alone in this assessment, as other titans like Orson Welles and Stanley Kubrick also ranked Cagney among the elite. It serves as a rare moment of total agreement between Hollywood heavyweights who usually occupied different corners of the industry.

Do you agree that James Cagney is the greatest actor of all time, or does another classic star deserve that title? Share your thoughts in the comments.