Finished ‘The Crash’ on Netflix? Discover Hulu Shows on the Mackenzie Shirilla Case

Since its premiere on May 15, Netflix’s ‘The Crash’ has been a hot topic in the true crime community. Many viewers are now turning to Hulu for additional insights, revealing a more troubling narrative about Mackenzie Shirilla than what the Netflix documentary presented.

‘The Crash’ focuses on Shirilla’s murder conviction linked to the deaths of her boyfriend, Dominic Russo, and friend Davion Flanagan. The documentary features Shirilla’s first on-camera interview since her trial, a significant moment as she had not spoken to law enforcement before or after her arrest, according to director Gareth Johnson and producer Angharad Scott.

In contrast, Hulu’s ‘Mean Girl Murders’ delves into aspects that Netflix overlooked. The episode titled ‘Under the Influence’ features interviews with Shirilla’s classmates, highlighting her aspirations to become a social media influencer. Classmate Jaina Maynard noted that she had confrontations with Shirilla due to her bullying behavior.

The Hulu episode reveals that Shirilla allegedly conducted a “dry run” of the crash route. Authorities found GPS data placing her at the accident site just three days prior, raising questions about her motives. This information, largely absent from the Netflix film, has sparked intense discussions online regarding the thoroughness of the case’s presentation.

Additionally, the episode disclosed that Shirilla reportedly maintained a list of individuals she disliked and her intentions toward them, as recounted by her classmates. Former friend Rachel Anderson stated that Shirilla was driven by a desire to be at the top and had never faced consequences for her actions until now.

Another Hulu offering, the ‘Killer Cases’ episode titled ‘Murder on Wheels,’ provides further context, particularly about Davion Flanagan’s background and the impact of the crash on his family. This episode includes footage from a police interview with Shirilla’s ex-boyfriend, Tyler Proctor, who suggested that she might have been attempting to take her own life during the crash.

In 2023, Shirilla was convicted on two counts of murder after prosecutors claimed she accelerated to 100 miles per hour without braking. She is currently serving two concurrent sentences of 15 years to life, with her first appeal already denied. Her family is committed to continuing the fight against her conviction.

Viewer feedback has largely favored the Hulu content, with one popular Reddit comment stating that the Netflix documentary failed to capture the full extent of the crash’s deliberateness. This has led many to recommend ‘Mean Girl Murders’ and ‘Killer Cases’ on Hulu for a more comprehensive understanding.

For those intrigued by true crime and who found ‘The Crash’ left them with more questions than answers, Hulu seems to be the platform where those answers await.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!