Milly Alcock’s ‘Supergirl’ Faces Challenges as Rotten Tomatoes Score Hits 61%

The new DC Universe is progressing with its second major film, but the initial reactions to ‘Supergirl’ have been mixed. Starring Milly Alcock as Kara Zor-El, the superhero movie has received its first round of reviews, providing fans insight into what critics think about DC Studios’ latest release.

Directed by Craig Gillespie and penned by Ana Nogueira, ‘Supergirl’ takes a fresh approach compared to earlier portrayals of the character. Rather than focusing on a conventional superhero origin story, the film follows Kara as she embarks on a perilous mission across the galaxy, filled with themes of revenge, loss, and self-discovery.

The film draws inspiration from the popular comic series ‘Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow’ by Tom King and Bilquis Evely. It is produced by DC Studios co-heads James Gunn and Peter Safran and is part of the inaugural chapter of the new DC Universe, titled ‘Gods and Monsters’.

As per Rotten Tomatoes, ‘Supergirl’ currently holds a 61% Tomatometer score from critics. While some reviewers have lauded Milly Alcock’s performance and the film’s visual aesthetics, others feel the narrative does not fully realize the potential of the iconic DC character.

Many reviewers have highlighted Alcock as the film’s standout element. Critics noted that she brings a refreshing energy to Kara Zor-El, making the character feel distinct from previous iterations of Supergirl. Kevin Maher from The Times delivered a negative review but still commended Alcock’s “swaggering charm and goofy energy,” stating that the actress is enjoyable even if the film around her falters.

Some critics appreciated the film’s darker and more grounded tone. Jeffrey Lyles of Lyles’ Movie Files described it as “a bleaker, more grounded and almost more (gasp) Snyder-like take” compared to James Gunn’s ‘Superman’. Others felt this unique style helped create a fresh version of Kara.

However, several reviewers pointed out that the story and supporting characters hindered the film from reaching its full potential. Jake Coyle of the Associated Press remarked that while the film has strong moments, it “struggles to match Kara’s punk-rock energy with an equally spirited supporting cast and story.” Matt Donato also felt that the movie left viewers wanting more due to some ideas not being fully fleshed out.

The action sequences and visual style garnered some positive remarks. Critics praised the film’s expansive universe, impressive visuals, and adventurous space elements. Some likened the film’s energy to other major sci-fi adventures, noting that it successfully creates an enjoyable cosmic journey.

Conversely, some critics felt the film did not fully encapsulate what makes Supergirl an engaging character. Carlos Aguilar from The Playlist compared Kara’s personality more to Tony Stark than Steve Rogers, suggesting that while the film gives her attitude and confidence, it struggles to construct a compelling emotional narrative around her.

Overall, critics concur that Milly Alcock is a significant highlight, offering audiences a Supergirl they will want to see again. The primary criticism is that the film’s script, supporting cast, and overall narrative do not consistently match the strength of Alcock’s performance. Consequently, it results in a superhero film with numerous good moments, yet some reviewers believe it falls short of being a standout entry in the DCU.

The movie follows Kara on her 23rd birthday as she journeys through space with her dog Krypto. During her travels, she encounters Ruthye Marye Knoll, and after a tragic event alters everything, Kara embarks on a mission fueled by anger and a thirst for revenge.

The cast also features Matthias Schoenaerts, Eve Ridley, David Krumholtz, Emily Beecham, David Corenswet, and Jason Momoa. With ‘Supergirl’ expected to play a crucial role in future DCU projects, the film’s reception could significantly influence the franchise’s direction.

While the Rotten Tomatoes score indicates a divided critical response, many agree that Milly Alcock is a standout aspect of the film. As audiences gear up to see the movie, the final verdict will hinge on whether fans resonate with this new iteration of Kara Zor-El and her role in the expanding DC Universe.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!