‘Supergirl’ Audience Score Surpasses Critics on Rotten Tomatoes

‘Supergirl’ is receiving mixed feedback from both audiences and critics, but initial responses indicate that fans are enjoying the new DC film more than professional reviewers. As per Rotten Tomatoes, the movie currently has a 58% rating from critics based on 195 reviews, while the audience score is significantly higher at 76% from over 500 verified ratings.

The disparity between these scores suggests that viewers and critics are perceiving the film quite differently. While some reviewers have pointed out that the film feels familiar and lacks originality, many fans have lauded its action sequences, character development, and ties to the DC universe.

Numerous audience members shared their opinions on Rotten Tomatoes after viewing the film. Some described it as a fun superhero adventure, while others felt it didn’t do enough to distinguish itself from other comic book adaptations.

One verified viewer remarked, “Lots of sass and kicking ass,” appreciating the film’s vibrant energy and style. Another fan commended the overall DC experience, stating, “if you like DC comic books or any comic book movies in general you’ll love this absolute banger.”

However, not all reactions have been favorable. Some viewers criticized the story for being too simplistic, with one reviewer calling it a “pretty bland hero flick.” Others pointed out issues with pacing and supporting characters. One audience member noted that the final battle felt prolonged, while another thought the storyline resembled a basic science-fiction adventure.

The new ‘Supergirl’ film features Milly Alcock in the role of Kara Zor-El, also known as Supergirl. The movie follows Kara as she embarks on a perilous space mission tied to revenge. The cast includes Jason Momoa as Lobo, along with Matthias Schoenaerts, Eve Ridley, David Krumholtz, Emily Beecham, and David Corenswet.

Directed by Craig Gillespie and penned by Ana Nogueira, ‘Supergirl’ is based on the DC Comics character and draws inspiration from the comic series ‘Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow’ by Tom King and Bilquis Evely. The film is produced by DC Studios heads James Gunn and Peter Safran and is part of the new DC Universe storyline.

This movie marks the second significant release in the new DCU following ‘Superman’ (2025). Milly Alcock first appeared as Supergirl in that film before taking the lead in her own solo adventure. Filming for ‘Supergirl’ took place in England and Scotland from January to May 2025.

The film premiered in Brooklyn on June 22, ahead of its wider release by Warner Bros. Pictures on June 26. It continues the first chapter of the DCU, titled Gods and Monsters.

While critics remain divided on ‘Supergirl’, the stronger audience score indicates that the film may resonate more with regular fans than with reviewers. This reaction also suggests that many viewers are eager to see a different portrayal of Kara Zor-El, particularly one featuring a darker narrative and a more serious tone.

As the DC Universe continues to shape its future, the reception of ‘Supergirl’ could serve as a crucial indicator of how audiences respond to the franchise’s new direction.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!