DCU’s ‘Lanterns’ Rotten Tomatoes Score Revealed — Is It Worth the Hype?

DC fans now have an early glimpse of how HBO’s ‘Lanterns’ is being received by critics, and the initial reviews are looking quite promising. The upcoming DC Universe series has achieved a 91% Tomatometer score on Rotten Tomatoes, marking a strong start ahead of its premiere on August 16.

‘Lanterns’ brings together two versions of Green Lantern for a unique superhero narrative. Kyle Chandler portrays Hal Jordan, a seasoned Lantern, while Aaron Pierre plays John Stewart, a new recruit who is just beginning to grasp the responsibilities of the role.

Rather than solely focusing on cosmic battles and superhero action, the series adopts a more grounded perspective. Hal and John find themselves embroiled in a murder investigation in the heartland of America, gradually unveiling a much larger mystery.

This detective angle has intrigued fans since the project’s announcement. According to the series’ official description, ‘Lanterns’ follows the two intergalactic officers as they investigate a murder on Earth. The narrative has been characterized as an original detective drama set within the DC Universe.

The creative team behind the show boasts significant television experience. Chris Mundy serves as the showrunner, with Damon Lindelof and comic book writer Tom King also contributing to the series’ development. The project is produced by DC Studios and Warner Bros. Television.

The cast extends beyond Chandler and Pierre, featuring Kelly Macdonald and Nathan Fillion in significant roles. Fillion is particularly familiar to DC fans, having previously portrayed Guy Gardner in ‘Superman.’

So, what are critics saying about ‘Lanterns’?

The current 91% Tomatometer score indicates a strongly positive early response. Critics seem to appreciate the show’s approach to the Green Lantern story, treating it as more than just a conventional superhero series. The murder mystery, realistic setting, and the dynamic between Hal and John are standout elements.

Robert Lloyd of the Los Angeles Times awarded the series a Fresh score, praising its originality, strong writing, performances, and meticulous attention to detail. Empire echoed this sentiment, giving Lanterns a 4/5 rating and noting its gritty, grounded style as a significant win for the DCU.

Several critics have highlighted the portrayal of John Stewart. Polygon’s Corey Plante commended how the narrative intertwines themes of fear and heroism with John’s identity as a Black man, suggesting the series provides more depth than typical superhero origin stories.

Kyle Chandler’s performance as Hal Jordan is another notable strength. Kathryn VanArendonk of Vulture praised his “sardonic” interpretation of Hal, stating he carries much of the series while John Stewart is still finding his footing. This dynamic hints that the chemistry between the two Lanterns could become one of the show’s greatest assets.

Other reviews have focused on the show’s mystery elements. JoBlo’s Alex Maidy rated Lanterns an impressive 9/10, describing it as a mature mystery reminiscent of HBO’s Watchmen and calling it a faithful adaptation of Green Lantern lore.

Grace Randolph of Beyond the Trailer also praised the central mystery, stating the series accurately portrays both Hal Jordan and John Stewart, calling it “perfect DC storytelling.”

Not every review is entirely positive. New York Times critic Mike Hale gave the series a Rotten score, arguing that Lanterns heavily emphasizes the darker emotional aspects of being a superhero.

Nevertheless, the overall consensus is clear: critics view Lanterns as a strong and mature addition to the new DCU, with its detective-story structure and character-driven approach distinguishing it from typical superhero content.

‘Lanterns’ is set to premiere on HBO on August 16, 2026, with eight episodes scheduled to air through October 4.

A 91% score is undoubtedly a strong start, especially for a series tasked with introducing two major Green Lantern characters to the new DCU. The real question remains whether the show can maintain this momentum once audiences experience the full season.

For now, critics seem to be providing DC fans with ample reasons to be excited. The blend of Green Lantern mythology, a murder mystery, and two distinct heroes could position ‘Lanterns’ as one of the most significant projects in the DCU.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!