Does Athena Truly Love Odysseus in Nolan’s ‘The Odyssey’?

The question of what connects the goddess Athena to the mortal king Odysseus remains unresolved in Greek mythology, and audiences exiting Christopher Nolan’s ‘The Odyssey’ find themselves pondering this age-old inquiry once again.

In the film, Zendaya portrays Athena, described in the production credits as the goddess of wisdom, warfare, and handicraft who safeguards Odysseus throughout his arduous journey. This role taps directly into one of the most debated dynamics in Homer’s works.

In the original epic, Athena’s loyalty to Odysseus appears less romantic and more akin to fierce, protective favoritism. She consistently intervenes on his behalf, disguises herself to guide his son Telemachus during his absence, and supports him because they share a knack for cunning and strategy.

This devotion has sparked centuries of scholarly debate regarding whether her feelings stem from loyalty, obsession, or something resembling love, and Nolan’s adaptation seems to embrace this ambiguity rather than provide a clear answer.

Critics have noted this ambiguity in the finished film. One review directly questioned whether Athena truly appears before Odysseus or if her presence is merely a manifestation of his guilt, serving as the only means of reckoning that could ultimately reunite him with his family. The review highlighted that Nolan’s script allows for either interpretation, a notably modern approach to a relationship that spans two millennia.

Several other reviews depict Athena as functioning more like an internal voice than a conventional deity. One critic described Odysseus as stoic in public but shown second-guessing his decisions during private moments with a vision of Athena, suggesting she serves as both his conscience and protector.

Another review went further, likening her appearances to a form of judgment, comparing her disapproving presence to the look a spouse gives when a chore is done incorrectly.

Not all critics view the dynamic as combative. One review portrayed Athena as an ethereal, almost ghostly figure who, alongside Odysseus’ second-in-command Eurylochus, serves as a sounding board representing the tension between gods and mortals throughout the journey. In a key exchange highlighted by another review, Zendaya’s Athena cautions Odysseus that his cleverness may lead him into trouble, a theme that unfolds as the film progresses.

Despite her reportedly limited screen time, Zendaya’s performance has been recognized as a significant contributor to the emotional depth of the film’s third act. Whether Nolan’s portrayal of Athena embodies love in any conventional sense may be secondary. The film appears more focused on whether that devotion, whether real or imagined, is what ultimately guides him home.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!