‘My Brilliant Career’ Season 1 Review: A Fresh Take on Sybylla Melvyn’s Journey

Miles Franklin’s semi-autobiographical novel, centered on a determined farm girl in the Australian bush, has retained its relevance since its publication in 1901. Now, Netflix presents a six-episode reimagining of this classic, helmed by showrunner Liz Doran, known for her work on ‘Barons’ and ‘Please Like Me’. The new series, titled ‘My Brilliant Career’, debuts on the platform this week.

The story continues to follow Sybylla Melvyn, an aspiring writer living a picturesque yet impoverished life on her family’s farm at Possum Gully. Her parents send her to live with her affluent grandmother, hoping she will abandon her literary dreams for a more conventional path.

Fans of the beloved 1979 film adaptation featuring Judy Davis and Sam Neill, as well as readers of the original novel, will find the premise familiar. However, Doran and her team have aimed to create a narrative that resonates with contemporary audiences rather than merely rehashing the past.

What stood out most in this new adaptation is its vibrant energy, which comes from portraying Sybylla not as a relic of the past but as a modern woman navigating her circumstances. She embodies a sharp-witted, impatient character who defies societal expectations, living in 1900 while thinking in the present.

Philippa Northeast’s portrayal of Sybylla is a key factor in the show’s success. She brings a restless energy to the role, making even the quieter moments feel charged with potential. Northeast skillfully balances Sybylla’s defiance with warmth, revealing depth through subtle expressions and interactions.

The series introduces two compelling romantic interests for Sybylla, avoiding the cliché of a clear-cut choice. Christopher Chung’s Harry begins as aloof but gradually reveals layers that make his connection with Sybylla feel authentic. Meanwhile, Jake Dunn’s Frank presents his own complexities as a man from England, adding depth to the romantic dynamics.

Visually, ‘My Brilliant Career’ is stunning, showcasing the sun-drenched landscapes of South Australia. Each location, from the humble stone cottage at Possum Gully to the expansive Five-Bob Downs, contributes its own unique atmosphere. The costumes and set designs feel authentic and lived-in, enhancing the story’s themes of class and appearance.

However, the soundtrack, which features contemporary pop songs reimagined in period-appropriate styles, elicited mixed feelings. While it occasionally enhances emotional moments, there are instances where it distracts from the show’s otherwise immersive 1900s setting. This minor issue does not overshadow the confident storytelling but does create moments that feel more like polished period cosplay.

Additionally, there were moments where the show could have trusted its audience more with its political themes. Sybylla’s feminist beliefs are sometimes articulated too overtly, rather than being conveyed through her actions. This is a minor critique in an otherwise nuanced narrative.

Overall, ‘My Brilliant Career’ is a beautifully crafted series that pays homage to its origins while establishing its own identity. With a standout lead performance, it leaves a lasting impression, making you reflect on Sybylla long after the credits roll. 9 out of 10.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!